These questions include two or more people with varying levels of efficiencies. Typical way in which this is provided is the total time taken by different individuals to complete the entire work. In these questions efficiency or rate of completion is to be taken as the portion of work a person can complete in 1 unit of time.
Portion of work completed in a day and time taken have a reciprocal relationship.
For example, if John can complete a piece of work in 20 days, then his efficiency is the portion of work he can complete in 1 day, which is 201th of the work.
Similarly, if Juliet can complete 61th of the work in 1 day, then she will take 6 days to complete the work.
Example 8
Salman and Aabid take 10 days and 20 days respectively to build a car. How long would they if they worked together?
Solution
Standard Unitary Method (Recommended)
Salman can finish 101th of the work in 1 day and Aabid can finish 201th of the work in 1 day.
Portion of work completed by Salman and Aabid in 1 day =101+201=203th of the work
Days taken to complete the work is the reciprocal of the portion of work completed in 1 day.
Days taken by Salman and Aabid together =220=6.67 days
Alternatively (Percentage Method)
Total work is taken as 100% and the portions of work completed by each can be expressed in percentage.
Salman can finish 101th or 10% of the work in 1 day and Aabid can finish 201th or 5% of the work in 1 day.
Portion of work completed by Salman and Aabid in 1 day =10%+5%=15%
Days taken =15%100%=6.67 days
Alternatively (Parts Method)
The number of parts in the work is the LCM of the time taken.
In this question, LCM (10,20)=20. So, let the total work be 20 parts.
In 1 day, Salman can finish 101th or 2 parts and Aabid can finish 201th or 1 part.
Parts completed by Salman and Aabid in 1 day =2+1=3 parts
Days taken =320=6.67 days
Answer: 6.67 days
The percentage method is useful if the fractions can be easily converted to percentages.
The parts method is the recommended method when work is done alternately (covered in Section 5 of this lesson).
The standard unitary method will be used for the rest of this lesson as it is simple to understand and apply.
Example 9
Alex and Graham, working alone, take 6 days and 8 days respectively to complete a piece of work. How many days will they take to finish the work if they worked together?
Solution
Portion of work completed by Alex in 1 day =61
Portion of work completed by Graham in 1 day =81
Portion of work completed by both together in 1 day =61+81=247
Therefore, time taken to complete the work together =724=3.43 days
Answer: 3.43 days
Note: In this question percentage method will be time consuming and difficult.
Example 10
A and B can finish a project working alone in 10 days and 20 days respectively. At the end of the fourth day, A leaves. At the beginning of the 6th day, C joins and starts working with B on the project. If the project is completed at the end of the 7th day, how long would C take to complete the project alone?
Solution
Portion of work completed by A and B in 1 day are 101 and 201 respectively.
Portion of work completed in 4 days =4×(101+201)=2012
Portion of work completed in 5 days =2012+201=2013
Portion of work completed on the 6th and 7th days =1−2013=207
Let x be the number of days C takes to complete the work alone.
⇒2×(201+x1)=207
⇒x2=205
⇒x=8 days
Answer: 8 days
Example 11
Shantanu can complete an assignment in 144 days, if he works for 9 hours everyday. Sayantan would take 72 days to complete the same assignment if he worked for 12 hours every day. If they are supposed to work together and complete the assignment in exactly 48 days, how many hours should they work for every day? (Assume they are required to work for the same amount of time every day)
The prime factors of all the numbers given in the questions are 2 and 3 only. Therefore, we can prime factorise and represent these numbers for ease in calculations.
Time taken by Shantanu to complete the assignment =144×9=24×34
Time taken by Sayantan to complete the assignment =72×12=25×33
Portion of work completed by Shantanu and Sayantan in 1 hour =24×341+25×331=25×345
Number of hours taken by Shantanu and Sayantan =525×34hours
If it takes 48 days to complete, then the hours/day they need to work for
=48days525×34hours=52×33=554
=1054 hours/day
Answer: 1054 hours
3.1 Groups with different efficiencies
Questions will include different groups of people or items. The efficiencies of individual members in a group will be constant. However, the efficiencies of the groups may be different and solved using linear equations.
Example 12
8 men and 3 women can assemble 20 cars in 8 days. 11 men and 6 women can assemble 20 cars in 5 days. How long would it take 10 men and 20 women to assemble 40 cars?
Solution
Let m and w be the portion of work completed by 1 man and 1 woman in 1 day respectively. And, let the work be defined as assembling 20 cars.
8m+3w=81 -----(1)
11m+6w=51 -----(2)
We proceed to find out the rate of completion of work of man and woman relative to each other.
8×(8m+3w)=5×(11m+6w)
⇒ 9m=6w
⇒ w=1.5m
Substituting in (2), 11m+9m=51 m=1001
So, w=1001.5
Portion of work completed by 10 men and 20 women in 1 day
=10010×1+10020×1.5=52=2.5
As assembling 40 cars is twice the defined work, they take 2×2.5=5 days
Answer: 5 days
Example 13
In Bilaspur village, 12 men and 18 boys completed construction of a primary health center in 60 days, by working for 7.5 hours a day. Subsequently the residents of the neighbouring Harigarh village also decided to construct a primary health center in their locality, which would be twice the size of the facility built in Bilaspur. If a man is able to perform the work equal to the same done by 2 boys, then how many boys will be required to help 21 men to complete the work in Harigarh in 50 days, working 9 hours a day? [IIFT 2011]
(1) 45 boys
(2) 48 boys
(3) 40 boys
(4) 42 boys
Solution
As 1 man's work is equal to that of 2 boys, we can convert the number of men to their equivalent in boys.
In Bilaspur village, 12 men (equivalent of 24 boys) and 18 boys worked on the center. Total boys equivalent is 24+18=42 boys.
Work to build a health center =40×60×7.5 boy-hours
Work to build twice the size of this health center =2×42×60×7.5=42×60×15 boy-hours
Note that we needn't multiply the terms here as some of them will get cancelled later.
Let the number of boys working in Harigarh be b. Number of men is 21, which is equivalent to 42 boys. They are to complete the work in 50 days working 9 hours a day.
(42+b)×50×9=42×60×15 boy-hours
⇒ b=42 boys
Answer: 42 boys
3.2 Special Case: 2 people working together
If A and B together take x days to complete a piece of work, while individually they take a days longer and b days longer to complete the same amount of work, then x=ab
Example 14
Abhi and Ram individually take 16 hours and 9 hours longer, respectively, than the time taken by them if they would have worked together. How long would Abhi, while working alone, take to complete work?
Solution
Let the time taken by Abhi and Ram while working together be x hours.
x=16×9=144=12 hours
∴ Abhi, while working alone, takes 12+16=28hours to complete the work.
Answer: 28 hours
Want to read the full content
Unlock this content & enjoy all the features of the platform